Polar vs. Garmin: Comparing Runner’s GPS Devices

Published on March 18 by Matt

For runners looking to optimize their training and track performance, choosing the right GPS watch is crucial. Two of the biggest brands in the market, Polar and Garmin, offer advanced running watches with a range of features tailored for athletes of all levels. While both provide accurate GPS tracking, heart rate monitoring, and training analysis, there are key differences that can influence which brand is best suited to your needs.

Design and Build Quality

Both Polar and Garmin watches are designed for durability and comfort. Garmin watches typically have a sleek, sporty design with customizable straps, while Polar watches often have a more minimalist, Scandinavian-inspired aesthetic.

• Garmin: Offers a wide range of models, from lightweight running watches to rugged, military-grade outdoor options.
• Polar: Focuses on ergonomic designs with high-contrast screens, ensuring readability in various lighting conditions.

GPS Accuracy and Performance

Both brands are known for their highly accurate GPS tracking, but Garmin has a slight edge due to its multi-band GNSS support (available in high-end models) for better accuracy in challenging environments.

• Garmin: Uses multiple satellite systems (GPS, GLONASS, Galileo) for precise tracking, even in urban or mountainous areas.
• Polar: Also provides strong GPS performance, though some users report slightly longer acquisition times in certain conditions.

Heart Rate Monitoring and Training Features

Heart rate tracking is essential for runners, and both brands offer wrist-based optical heart rate monitors.

• Garmin: Features advanced heart rate analytics, recovery metrics, and training load insights.
• Polar: Known for superior heart rate accuracy, especially with the Polar Precision Prime sensor technology.

Training and Coaching Features

Both brands provide coaching and training plans, but their approaches differ:

• Garmin: Offers Garmin Coach, VO2 max estimates, lactate threshold calculations, and advanced race predictions.
• Polar: Features Polar Flow, which provides personalized adaptive training based on your fitness level and goals.

Battery Life

Battery life is a key factor for endurance athletes.

• Garmin: Typically offers longer battery life, especially in GPS mode. High-end models like the Garmin Enduro can last up to 70 hours with GPS enabled.
• Polar: Provides decent battery life, with some models lasting up to 40 hours in GPS mode.

Smartwatch Features and Connectivity

Garmin watches often come with more smartwatch-like features, including:

• Music storage and playback
• Contactless payments (Garmin Pay)
• Third-party app support (Spotify, Strava, etc.) Polar focuses more on fitness and training features but still offers basic notifications and smartphone connectivity.

Price and Value

• Garmin: Offers a broader range of prices, from budget-friendly models (Garmin Forerunner 55) to premium options (Garmin Fenix 7, Epix 2).
• Polar: Generally offers a more affordable entry price, making it an excellent option for those who want solid training features without the high cost.

Conclusion: Which One Should You Choose?

• Choose Garmin if you want longer battery life, advanced performance metrics, and smartwatch features.
• Choose Polar if you prioritize accurate heart rate monitoring, personalized training guidance, and a more affordable price.

Both brands offer excellent GPS watches for runners, and the best choice depends on your specific training needs and budget.

---